President Bush's Pro-Life Views Will Prevail Over HHS Secretary's
Opinion of Stem Cell Research
(CNSNews.com) - President Bush's pro-life views
will prevail, regardless of statements about stem
cell research made by his secretary of health and
human services, said one spokesperson for the
National Right to Life Committee.
"I'm certain Bush will do the right thing," said
Darla St. Martin, associate executive director for
the group.
HHS Secretary Tommy Thompson was speaking before a
U.S. Senate committee Tuesday when he criticized
the stem cell research law that bans federal
funding for studies involving the destruction of
human embryos. Confusion ensued after the hearing
when Thompson's staffers reportedly announced that
the secretary meant to relay the opposite message
-- that he, in fact, supported the ban.
Denounced by pro-lifers as the killing of humans,
embryonic stem cell research is also scorned by
Bush, said St. Martin, who expects the president's
views will win out, regardless of the confusion
surrounding Thompson's statements.
Others, however, are not so sure, and demand that
Bush "immediately issue an executive order
banning" the research procedure because Thompson
is currently allowing scientists to submit
applications for grants to perform the stem cell
studies.
"Secretary Thompson is misinformed on this life
and death issue," said American Life League's
Cathy Brown, in a prepared statement. "He needs to
be reined in on this illicit, if not illegal,
attempt to circumvent the law," using grant
application rules that are "based on corrupt
National Institutes of Health guidelines."
Congress has prohibited federal funds to be used
for embryonic research, but the Clinton
administration interpreted the law to allow for
the NIH to pay for such studies if the stem cells
had been derived from private sources.
In January of 2001, the NIH updated its research
guidelines in line with the Clinton
administration's interpretations, and clarified
that "pluripotent cells" were not the same as
embryos, and were therefore not subject to the
same funding prohibitions.
However valued the pluripotent stem cells are for
their perceived unlimited research potential,
pro-life groups insist the cells are still derived
from fetal tissues and embryos, the latter of
which is destroyed during the extraction process.
"For studies using human pluripotent stem cells
derived from human embryos, NIH funds may be used
only if the cells were derived from frozen embryos
that were created for the purposes of fertility
treatment, were in excess of clinical need, and
were obtained after the consent of the donating
couple," according to the NIH's January fact sheet
on stem cell research guidelines.
Scientists wishing to conduct pluripotent stem
cell research using grant funds from the NIH have
until mid-March to apply.
It's Thompson's acceptance of such grant
applications that has upset such organizations as
the American Life League, who consider his actions
supportive of what they view as a life-killing
process. St. Martin, though, insisted that the
current secretary's receipt of the funding
requests does not necessarily mean he favors the
research.
"That [grant program] was already in process
during the Clinton administration, and before the
election," she said. "That doesn't mean anything
... because the next step is to actually award
these grants," and Thompson may not proceed with
the actual disbursement of funds.
Thompson did, however, announce a presidential
initiative to increase funding to the NIH grant
program during another Congressional hearing
Wednesday.
"The NIH is the largest and most distinguished
biomedical research organization in the world," he
said. "For fiscal year 2002, we are proposing an
increase of $2.75 billion, which will be the
largest increase ever for NIH. This funding level
will enable NIH to support the highest level of
total research grants in the agency's history."
By Cheryl K. Chumley
CNS Staff Writer
March 08, 2001
Copyright 2001 Jay Sekulow and ACLJ
Be a TLC Lifeguard
Before You Leave...
We hope you enjoy our web site and find it useful as a resource center.
Please take a moment to rate our site.
Will you help?
Will you help us continue to make this resource
available to thousands of monthly visitors from around the world?
Yes
Texans for Life Coalition
P.O. Box 177727
Irving, TX 75017-7727
(972) 790-9044
webservant@texlife.org
|