Does the Unborn Baby Feel Pain?
Unborn babies may feel pain beginning with the seventeenth week of
gestation suggests Professor Vivette Glover of the Queen Charlotte's and
Chelsea Hospital in London, UK. Although admittedly "pro-choice,"
Professor Glover has spoken and written on the subject of fetal pain
many times in the past several years and will chair a British conference
on the controversial topic in November. Having studied the pain
responses in very young neonates--some of whom were the same gestational
age as children who undergo abortion--she has concluded that it is
possible for them to experience suffering.
Many experts agree. In fact, some doctors place the probable threshold
several weeks earlier, and numerous scientists around the world believe
that embryos can feel pain at least by the eighth week of pregnancy.
"This is more evidence that human life exists at the moment of
conception. We have known it all along, and I suspect that everybody
else knows it subconsciously, but will not admit it," observes Mr. Kevin
Male of the pro-life organization Life.
Those who disagree, however, claim that fetal responses indicative of
pain in more mature individuals (flinching, movement, even measurable
increases in fetal stress hormones) represent only reflex reactions.
Chairperson of the Induced Abortion Guideline Group of the Royal College
of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists', Dr. Gillian Penney asserts that
fetuses younger than 26 weeks cannot feel pain because the connections
in the brain between the cortex and the thalamus are not yet fully
developed. Further, some scientists link suffering with self-awareness
and contend that fetuses are not self-aware, despite reports that
aborted babies as young as 21 weeks have been known to cry.
But there is insufficient evidence to prove either view, argues
Professor Peter Hepper of Queen's University in Belfast, Northern
Ireland. In principle, however, his position is similar to Professor
Glover's. In the absence of certainty, he would rather "be safe than
sorry," he says.
Professor Glover has sparked controversy by recommending that all
abortions from the seventeenth week onward be performed under
anesthesia. Although she continues to support abortion, she asserts
that "one should not muddle the two. One should think about how one is
doing [the abortion] in the most pain-free way." While science may not
yet be able to determine when a pre-term child is sufficiently developed
to experience pain, Professor Glover says, "Between 17 and 26 [weeks] it
is increasingly possible that it starts to feel something and that
abortions done in that period ought to use anaesthesia."
Source: London Telegraph, August 28, 2000
Be a TLC Lifeguard
Before You Leave...
We hope you enjoy our web site and find it useful as a resource center.
Please take a moment to rate our site.
Will you help?
Will you help us continue to make this resource
available to thousands of monthly visitors from around the world?
Yes
Texans for Life Coalition
P.O. Box 177727
Irving, TX 75017-7727
(972) 790-9044
webservant@texlife.org
|